skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Catered a party and I was pleasantly surprised. I wasn't expecting much but everything they delivered was great. The quality was certainly heads above a "cafeteria," but maintained some very homey charm in every dish. I'd do it again.
G K via google.com - Sep 14, 2021
Still a great dining experience must go again ... read more
William P. South Jr. via google.com - Sep 14, 2021
First time I've been there in yrs. Food was good and they handled an overflow crowd with it.
Kevin Sochor via google.com - Sep 12, 2021
Mehlmans Cafeteria is excellent and can't b beat .
Thomas Edgell via google.com - Sep 10, 2021
Oh my goodness, we went there by chance we where heading up to Indiana in a family road trip than we got hungry we wanted to eat so we saw this place and we went in , what a nice place clan a lot of food ditches in the display. Its so delicious everything and the portions are just right , the employs are friendly and welcome the cust ... read more
Maria Lopez via google.com - Sep 9, 2021
A wonderful family owned cafeteria style restaurant. The food is delicious. Piano music is being played in the background.
Deb Highley via google.com - Sep 5, 2021
Good food, many choices ... read more
Jan Nixon via google.com - Aug 20, 2021
Their mash potatoes are hevenly and their service is great. Be prepared to see a bunch of old people
Their mash potatoes are hevenly and their service is great. Be prepared to see a bunch of old people. Dont get me started on their pumkin pie!!!!
Patrick Y. via yelp.com - Aug 20, 2021
Excellent Food and Service Dont want to eat at any other place but HERE give them 10 stars!!!!!!
GREG POLVERINI via google.com - Aug 17, 2021
Love Mehlman's ... read more
Ken Garloch via google.com - Aug 12, 2021
Mehlman's knows what it is and what it isn't, and they do what they do very well. Good cafeteria food at great price. Average age of customers -- 86? ... read more
Jawbox via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
THE FOOD explains why this was My Grandparents favorite place to dine in a🥘t🍽...Just delicious 😋 ... read more
Jeremy garrett via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
Great food at a great price!
Tina Troy-White via google.com - Aug 5, 2021
Always awesome. Best cafeteria I've ever visited.
Jeff Aliff via google.com - Aug 4, 2021
Cafeteria style food. Ooooohhhhh so good. Great selection. Great prices. Nice family atmosphere. Roast beef is my all time favorite. 😋😋😋 ... read more
cheryl gordon via google.com - Aug 3, 2021
Wonderful food! Cafeteria style serving, reasonable prices, excellent food; good selection of entrees and sides ... read more
Debbie Davis via google.com - Aug 2, 2021
Always had a good experience going here, easy to get my grandmother in and out with out alot of walking for her.
Aaron Agnew via google.com - Aug 2, 2021
Their food reminds me of home. Decently crowded, so plan accordingly.
Vanessa Campbell via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Not too crowded. Great selection of hot food to choose from. And the pies!!!! So yummy!!!
Nicole Hovanick via google.com - Jul 30, 2021
Great Food and Service.My wife's new favorite.I would pick this place over any other place.
Greg Polverini via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
Cafeterias are endangered species. What once was a stable of middle class and working class American dining options is now all but lost. I stop at Mehlman's while I'm in route to NYC via Pittsburgh. The food is simple good home cooking. Where else can you get an individual molded jello these days? Some may call it "dated"....but tho ... read more
Justin via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
Excellent Food and Service give them 10 stars!!!!!!
GREG POLVERINI via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
Homemade greatness! A must stop if you're in the area!
Jason Dennis via google.com - Jul 23, 2021
Service and food was outstanding. If you love fried fish you have to try the Canadian white fish.
Shelly Cleckley via google.com - Jul 19, 2021
Everything on the menu is amazing, and great prices. Love this cafeteria!
amy wey via google.com - Jul 19, 2021
Great, inexpensive cafeteria style restaurant.
Christy H via google.com - Jul 18, 2021
Excellent food, clean place, nice people and fancy atmosphere.
Eric Hill via google.com - Jul 18, 2021
Excellent Ribs best I've had in a while. My first visit for sure I'll return ... read more
Joseph Lundy via google.com - Jul 17, 2021
Great food and very good prices.
Steven S via google.com - Jul 15, 2021
Food is excellent , been there many times and have never had anything that was not good.
Richard Welch via google.com - Jul 15, 2021
We ride our bikes to hit a couple of states stopped here to eat and didn't want to leave. Everything was great!
Lisa Bradford via google.com - Jul 10, 2021
A great place to stop for a quick affordable and a delicious meal ... read more
Chuck Morris via google.com - Jul 9, 2021
This is a clean but, dated cafeteria. However, the food is always very good.
Thom Platt via google.com - Jun 28, 2021
If you want a good home style cooked meal at an affordable price this is it. We have been eating here for over 40 years and always leave satisfied. This cafeteria has the best roast beef and homemade mashed potatoes and gravy. Love the desserts too.
William Loughrie via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
Great food and service ... read more
George Garrison via google.com - Jun 6, 2021
This is a one of a kind find. Great food!
H Bisk via google.com - Jun 6, 2021
The food we got was very good, but they were out of the 2 main courses that we specifically went there for. Pecan pie was average, at best. It was a quiet setting, but quite warm inside, and the piano music was kind of strange. Prices and selections were great, and we would go back for sure.
Shawn Kelly via google.com - Jun 3, 2021
It was fantastic, came from Georgia,. I will return ... read more
Maria Helms via google.com - May 31, 2021
Very good food reasonable prices ... read more
David Majlinger via google.com - May 30, 2021
Best pies I ever had. Can buy them if you call them in early.
Sandra Stillion via google.com - May 28, 2021
What a wonderful buffet, would definitely return when in the area.
Susan Spencer via google.com - May 25, 2021
Awesome food old fashioned recipes yummy ... read more
Paul Davis via google.com - May 23, 2021
Always great Love curb service Im disabled and this is wonderful ... read more
sharon hanson via google.com - May 20, 2021
Good food ... read more
Jerri Sterling via google.com - May 17, 2021
I've been going to Mehlman's since I was a little girl and the food is just as great now as it was then.
Sharon Meisenhelter via google.com - May 17, 2021
Super friendly atmosphere. Excellent home style food. Crisp salad.
Sondra Shreve via google.com - May 16, 2021
A favorite place with lots of loyal customers. Homemade bread and pies. Good home cooking.
Vicki Sexton via google.com - May 12, 2021
Quintessential comfort food. Friendly staff. Extremely fair pricing.
Mary Davis via google.com - May 3, 2021
Great food, good prices. Definitely will go back.
Tina Cox via google.com - May 2, 2021
My favorite place to eat . My husband and I just love the cabbage and noodles .
Carol Zevatsky via google.com - Apr 30, 2021
It's a nice little place to get some "home cooked" meals in a cafeteria setting. The pie is always good and the people have always been the sweetest.
Juliana Sowinski via google.com - Apr 25, 2021
I love the home cooking without me having to clean up. Delicious food with no complaints from any of our party. Except my 2 1/2 year old granddaughter who didn't like the jello that she picked because it had nuts in it. Hahaha. We had a family welcome hostess that replaced it without charge and my granddaughter loved it! She didn't w ... read more
Kay Sowinski via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
i love this place. friendly workers and very good food ... read more
Gee Gee via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Great traditional cafeteria food, good quality and quantity, always clean and staff is friendly and helpful.
Larry Yoho via google.com - Apr 23, 2021
Perfect home cooked meal. There were 6 of us and all 6 say 5 STARS ... read more
Marsha Parker via google.com - Apr 23, 2021
Always top notch !!!
Aaron Huffman via google.com - Apr 23, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire